By: Allison McCarthy, MBA | amccarthy@barlowmccarthy.com
Mid level leaders are in a unique position. You sit close enough to the front lines to see real challenges unfold, but you’re also connected upward enough to understand what leaders expect. This vantage point gives you the opportunity, and responsibility, to influence in every direction.
The truth is, influence isn’t about title or hierarchy. It’s about how consistently you build credibility, foster trust, and adapt your presence to the situation.
The question is: how do you do it with impact?
Why Influence Matters
In a “just world,” we’d assume that hard work and good intentions are always recognized and rewarded. But in the real world, influence comes from more than effort. Contributions matter, but so do relationships. Competence is important, but so is how you carry yourself in the room.
For middle managers, this reality is both a challenge and an opportunity: you can either wait for recognition, or you can proactively strengthen your influence so your ideas and efforts land with impact.
The Four Core Components of Influence
Influence is built on four interdependent components:
1. Expertise
More than knowledge, expertise combines skill, judgment, and the ability to apply learning in ways others value. Leaders with expertise:
- Offer sound judgment when stakes are high
- Recognize patterns that others miss
- Continue to grow and adapt as circumstances change
2. Gravitas
Often described as “executive presence,” gravitas is about how you project steadiness and strength under pressure. It includes:
- Confidence: trusting your ability to find the answer, adapt, and act
- Decisiveness: making clear choices, even with incomplete information
- Passion: showing energy and purpose that motivate others
Gravitas doesn’t mean being flawless. It means being credible, humble, and composed in the moments that matter most.
3. Communication
Communication is the influence tool you use every day. Skilled leaders:
- Listen actively and reflect back what they’ve heard
- Adapt their message for executives, peers, or frontline staff
- Bring clarity, not confusion
- Reframe obstacles into possibilities
Knowing your own tendencies and the preferences of your audience, is essential. Sometimes it’s about standing on the “balcony,” pulling back from details to see patterns and frame the big picture. Other times, it’s about translating strategy into clear next steps for your team.
4. Reference (Respect and Likeability)
Respect is earned over time through consistent behavior and follow-through.
Likeability, while subjective, is often built through small habits: being approachable, asking questions, and showing genuine interest.
Both matter. Without them, expertise and gravitas don’t land.
Trust as the Anchor
If respect is the door, trust is the anchor. Trust is fragile: it takes consistent action to build and only a single misstep to fracture. Ask yourself: Where is there a trust challenge with a stakeholder group? Which component of influence is missing, and what can I do to shift their perspective?
Leaders strengthen trust by:
- Following through on commitments
- Owning outcomes, good or bad
- Being open to feedback and willing to grow
Presence in Pressure Moments
Every leader faces moments where composure is tested: a tense meeting, a frustrated executive, or an unexpected crisis. In those moments, your presence becomes your influence.
Presence isn’t about perfection, it’s about how you regulate your emotions, steady your voice, and project credibility. From posture and body language to clarity of tone, presence tells others whether they can count on you.
Ask colleagues for honest feedback: How would you rate my presence in high-pressure settings? What’s one shift that would strengthen it?
Building Influence Up, Down, and Across
The best leaders are agile: they shift their influence depending on direction.
Upward influence means bringing clarity to executives, staying succinct, and framing issues in ways that highlight strategic implications.
Downward influence means creating clarity for teams, asking questions that unlock obstacles, and modeling calm under pressure.
Across influence means building peer relationships, showing respect, and earning trust so collaboration flows instead of stalls.
The balance is delicate: too much focus on pleasing one group at the expense of others erodes credibility. The middle leader’s power is in holding all three directions in view.
From Operational to Strategic
It’s easy to get stuck in day-to-day execution. But influence grows when you can zoom out– what Ronald Heifetz calls “standing on the balcony.” From the balcony, you notice patterns, themes, and opportunities that others miss. You see connections across teams and anticipate challenges before they surface.
Executives value mid-level leaders who bring not only solutions, but also perspective. Frontline staff value leaders who can translate strategy into actionable clarity.
The mid-level leader who can toggle between these perspectives is indispensable.
Putting It Into Practice
Influence isn’t developed in a single program or achieved through one big shift. It’s built through small, daily habits:
- Listen with intent, not just to respond
- Reframe challenges into possibilities
- Ask questions that reveal unspoken concerns
- Adapt your communication to the person in front of you
Track when you use one small influence habit, and its impact.
Key Takeaway
Influence is not a trait reserved for those at the top. It’s a discipline those that lead from the middle can practice every day by carrying themselves with gravitas, communicating with clarity, earning respect, and anchoring trust.
Every meeting, every conversation, and every decision is a chance to strengthen your influence.
Start small, stay consistent, and watch how your presence in the middle becomes the launchpad for your leadership future.
–––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––
For more tools to strengthen your presence and expand your influence, download my free guide: Leading Up, Down, and Across from the Middle: Grow Where You Are, Then Grow Beyond.